Welcome to Rome: Total War Heaven
Welcome
Downloads Home
Best Files
Review Guidelines
Main site
Forums
Code of Conduct
Search

Advanced Search
Battle Videos
Home
New Releases
New Reviews
New Comments
Top-Rated

Submit File
Browse Categories
New Files

Downloads Home » Battle Videos » Rome vs Carthage Nailbiting battle

Download File Post Review Post Comment

Rome vs Carthage Nailbiting battle

Author File Description
scipio_africanus
File Details
Number of Players: 2
Player 1's Name: HG{[Crusader]}RomanJuli{E} (Carthage)
Player 2's Name: HG_scipio_africanus (Brutii)
# of Denarii: 15k each
This game is the most exciting I have played since the FP seige several months ago.

A game which is even all the way through seems to be over, but is it?

A well matched, fast-paced game with no bvoring moments and a thrilling finale.

Enjoy!
AuthorReviews   ( All | Comments Only | Reviews Only )
Rookierookie
Rating
4.0
Rating: 4
How careless can a person get? There was no way the battle could have been lost after the elephants smashed into the rear of the Brutii army, yet he managed to completely squander each of the MANY opportunities after his elephants ran amok.

Both armies had...unusual lineups, the Brutii army having Urbans and...town watch? The town watches were somewhat useful in being onager fodder and as a cheap way to fight the onagers, but I would have gotten Roman archers instead. Nevermind. The Carthage army had Sacred Band and Libyan spearmen, which proved their uselessness over and over again in this battle.

The pila was wasted on the onagers; Urban cohorts could easily have taken them on without using them, saving it for the more dangerous Sacred Bands.

Both sides were quite careless when it came to the flanking battle, The Roman Julii trying to charge two Libyan Spearmen into EIGHT Praetorian cavalry, and scipio_africanus reacting very slowly in attacking the Sacred Band cavalry.

I was constantly astounded by the maneuvers the Sacred Band were doing. It appeared from the replay that the Sacred Band were given move commands in the midst of a battle against Urbans, leading to melee and defeat when they could have just stayed in formation and mauled the Urbans. There was also a flanking maneuver by Sacred Bands that failed miserably when The Roman Julii put his troops on phalanx right before they could have hit the Urbans and causing a mass rout, which probably lost him two Sacred Band units.

Over all, very entertaining to watch, as well as being a lesson on what not to do when commanding phalanxes.

- Firefox @ The RTWH Review Team

Post Review Post Comment

HGDL v0.8.0

Login
Forum Username:


Password:




Create a new account
Forgot password?
Rating
4.0
Statistics
Downloads:962
Favorites: [Who?]0
Size:38.98 KB
Added:05/28/05