Review Guidelines - Battle Videos
Generally, try not to rate battle videos unless you think it was a really awesome game. Make your review of Battle Videos long enough to thoroughly explain why you gave the rating you did. Try not to rate on skill level, suggestions for what the player could have done are great, reviews stating that "These guys suck." are not. There are a few rare cases that a couple sentences may be adequate, but these are the exception rather then the rule. The bottom line is that a good review will always be lengthy enough to thoroughly explain the reviewer's choice of rating. A review consisting solely of "This recorded game was pretty cool" or "This recorded game sucked" simply won't cut it and will be removed. If you want to post something like that post it as a comment.
Back to the Table of Contents
Thanks to Spineman, Rasher, Gill and everyone else who has worked on the numerous review guidelines all over Heavengames. This review guideline is based on, and incorporates many of their ideas.