Review Guidelines - Campaigns
You have a choice of rating each file from 1 to 5. Decimal scores can be given if you feel the file isn't quite a full number value.
5.0 - Outstanding
Only to be given to the best of campaigns. There should be no problems and nothing you feel that can be improved upon on. If it's of the same quality of the official campaign map this is the score it should receive.
4.0 - Excellent
If you think the campaign you're rating is better than average, but hasn't reached the perfection of the official campaign map, give this score.
3.0 - Average
A good, playable campaign; no glaring problems, but still things that can be improved.
2.0 - Below Average
Mediocre or with errors or many points that need improving, but the campaign can be played and completed.
1.0 - Well Below Average
The lowest score you can give. For example, if there's bug that makes the campaign unplayable it's a 1.0.
Back to the Table of Contents
Thanks to Spineman, Rasher, Gill and everyone else who has worked on the numerous review guidelines all over Heavengames. This review guideline is based on, and incorporates many of their ideas.